Lyrically and vocally, this song would establish a Knowles trademark, one that (in my opinion, as always) sets her apart from the cohort of R&B divas on today's market: her near-complete capacity to go bat-shit insane on a track. On this one, she's not just in love - she's crazy in love. It's that kind of rampant energy that puts her at that Queen spot.** (Mariah used to be there. Now she's all bloated. Yikes.)
It is here that you should know: I am a raving mad Jay-Z fan, and will habitually give him between 50 and 2,000 percent more credit than he deserves. But, damnit, it's his wry brilliance here that really makes the track tip over into "smash hit" territory (and gives this post its title). As with his earlier sixteen-bar turn on Mariah's "Heartbreaker", Mr. Carter plays a simple role - coy, seemingly detached object of feminine love - with ease.
* Think about the way the titles of the sampled and sampling songs fit together. The Chi-Lites ask "Are you my woman?"; Beyonce answers "yes", and leaves no damn room for further questioning.
** I devoted some tweets to this topic, along the way managing to compare Beyonce to George Costanza. Twitter is fun.
I'm just glad that you have a proper venue for this. I can't agree more that, sadly, Mariah lost her queen status some decade ago... If italicized crazy and rampant energy are the prerequisites for being a queen, will we see Queen GaGa someday?
ReplyDeleteGaGa = Princess of Pop right now, IMO.
ReplyDelete